Friday, December 5, 2025

Cowboy Christmas Wishlists: What He Wanted vs. What He Gave His Gal


 

Growing up, the Wish Book was basically my version of Pinterest. My sisters and I would sprawl out on the floor, circling everything from sparkly shoes to toys.

Then I stumbled on a reproduction of the 1893 Sears catalogue, and oh boy, talk about rabbit holes. If cowboys had Amazon Prime, this would’ve been it. I picked out a few favorites to share—with their original descriptions, because they’re too good not to.

What Every Cowboy Hoped Santa Would Leave in His Saddlebag

Cowboys didn’t hang stockings by the fire. Presents were practical, sometimes romantic, and often dusted with trail grit. Forget diamonds and toy trains—these gifts had spurs and sass.


A hat that could survive Wyoming windstorms. Good luck with that.

Coffee beans by the pound--the real liquid gold of the West.

A fresh pair of sock--rarer than gold, worth more than whiskey.

A Bible or dime novel--to read by lantern light.

A new saddle or boots--a must have for every cowboy.


A harmonica, so he could annoy the whole bunkhouse with “Oh! Susanna.”


                                        Gifts not found in a catalogue

A letter from home—because even cowboys got homesick.

One more season alive, riding, and not trampled by cattle

Homemade Soaps—made at by hand so he could scrub off the trail dirt.

Things a Cowboy Would Get His Sweetheart for Christmas

Peppermint sticks or lemon drops to tell her that she’s sweet.

Lace or a  ribbon for her hair--the cowboy version of jewelry-on-a-budget.

A length of fabric – sew-your-own-dress kit.

A shawl or gloves – practical, but he swears they’re “pretty, too.”

Perfume or soap – a rare splurge, and a subtle hint that trail dust isn’t a turn-on.

Personal Gifts not found in a catalogue.

A small A hand-carved trinket – sure, it’s crooked, but it’s made with love (and a pocketknife).

A kiss under the mistletoe – because sometimes the best gift doesn’t cost a dime.

A promise—spoken under the stars—that she was his forever gift.

Photos from the 1893 Sears, Roebuck & Company Catalogue and Montgomery Ward & Com. Catalogue 1895




1 comment:

Julie Lence said...

Love this! He had quite a wish list and gift list. Thank you for sharing, Niki!