Monday, November 16, 2026

Murderess of Slaughterhouse Gulch

 


Every gold rush town had its dark side—outlaws, claim jumpers, saloons, and gunfights. But nestled in the sagebrush hills Wyoming, the historic ghost town of South Pass City harbors a story far more sinister than a simple saloon brawl.

 It’s the story of Polly Bartlett, often dubbed the "Murderess of Slaughterhouse Gulch" or the "Deadly Damsel of South Pass." Depending on who you ask, Polly was either Wyoming’s most cold-blooded female serial killer who poisoned 22 men for their gold... or one of the greatest hoaxes in Wild West folklore.


South Pass City was booming in 1868. The county seat of Carter County, later changed to Sweetwater County in 1969. The Clarissa Mine and others like it drew miners in from all over. The Sweetwater gold rush was in full swing, turning South Pass City from a quiet trail stop into a booming frontier metropolis packed with thousands of prospectors, gamblers, and merchants carrying pockets full of gold dust.


 
Among those arriving to seek their fortune, were Polly Bartlett and her father, Jim (or Stephen or John depending on source), a teenage son and a housekeeper. They left Cincinnati and settled in Colorado for a time but soon left. In Denver they bought arsenic that was used to kill rodents. The family had pitched their tent three miles from South Pass City to rest their cattle.

The first victim. Lewis Nichols was a successful prospector and stopped at the camp on his way bast east. He smelled the food the family was cooking and said he would give them $10 for a meal. Lewis made the mistake of showing the family a roll of greenbacks. Polly hatched the perfect plan to take that money. The steak she gave Nichols was sprinkled with arsenic.

Nichols died and Polly counted her new fortune while her father buried the body in the stock corral. The next morning when it was time to move on, Polly persuaded her family to stay and continue making a profit off the travelers.

Polly’s plan

  1. Robbery: They stripped the victim of his gold coins, dust, and valuables.
  2. Concealment: They buried the body in a shallow grave inside the livestock corral, covering the disturbed earth with manure and hay.
  3. Repeat: For months, miners mysteriously disappeared along the road to South Pass City, but in a chaotic boomtown where men routinely died of exposure, attacks, or sudden departures, nobody raised the alarm.

She repeated her plan 22 times.

Suspicion grew.

Theodore Fortune was on break from college and scheduled to arrive in South Pass City to visit his dad, Barney, in August 1868, before returning to college. When he failed to return a letter from Barney’s sister confirmed that he had in fact left. The Pinkerton Detective Agency was hired to trace Theodore’s journey. They foiled the trail to the Bartlett Inn where it disappeared.

When questioned Polly cried and said she had warned Theodore not to travel at night, but he had gone anyway.


The one that got away.

A cattle buyer visiting his brother in South Pass City stopped at the Bartlett inn. Polly too him out to see the cattle then invited him to go with her to the hayloft for a good time. In the loft, her father appeared with an axe that he leaned against the wall and set down a pint of whiskey, telling Polly it was for her use in entreating the young man.

Thankfully no matter how much Polly urged him to drink, he told her he was a total abstainer and would not drink. He left the loft and rode away. When he got to South Pass City he told his brother what had happened.

 

Feeling too many people were getting suspicious, the Bartlett family left in such a hurry they left their cattle behind. The next day it was said they family was gone and that prompted a search of the barn and house. They discovered fresh digging where they cattle had eaten all the hay. Twenty- two bodies were found. Several bodies were identified. Theodore Fortune’s body was identified by a gold belt buckle his father had given him. Sam Ford was identified by his Misonic ring.


Edmond Ford, (Sam's brother) tracked the family and killed Jim Bartlett. The housekeeper and son were released to continue their journey. Polly was placed in the county jail, awaiting trial.

Otto Kalkhorst, a mine boss employed by Barney Fortune, rode to the jail and entered the jail to shoot Polly with a double barreled shotgun. She was killed.

 Different sources give different names of the victims and the man that killed Jim. Some say that Edmond Ford was the cattle buyer that declined the whiskey and escaped with his life.

Truth or myth???

There is no actual evidence that Polly Barlett was Wyoming's Deadly Damsal. It's a very interesting legend though.


South Pass City is a thriving little ghost town. You can tour the Clarissa Mine and see what is left of the town. It is quite literally in the middle of nowhere Wyoming, but worth the visit.

No comments: